MC Frontalot
BBS :: Who Wants Pie? :: Thread
Previous thread :: Next thread
Sitcom Battle!
Which show do you prefer?
25%
30 Rock [ 25% / 3 ]
16%
It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia [ 16% / 2 ]
58%
I have not watched one or either of these shows. [ 58% / 7 ]
Total Votes : 12
Previterror
hypernerd
Posts: 915
Location: Boise, ID
Reply with quote
Posted 4.27.10 :: 3:22AM :: Sitcom Battle!
This thread has been created expressly for the comparison of the shows "30 Rock" and "It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia". I'll open by explaining my feelings on the shows.

-I find the characters and their interactions to be consistently amusing on 30 Rock, with the odd clever reference thrown in.

-In my experience, It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia is simply a string of lewd, ignorant, or base jokes or situations.
View user's profileSend private messageSend emailAIM AddressYahoo MsgrMSN Msgr
MC-3PO
metanerd
Posts: 704
Location: the Death Star, Kirkland, WA
Reply with quote
Posted 4.27.10 :: 11:24AM ::
So basically you're looking to start an argument. Okay.

I prefer 30 Rock overall, as I find it to be packed with clever jokes and smartly-timed one-liners that tend to enhance even their stalest plots. While I feel it has flagged some over the years, the moment-to-moment jokes are as sharp as they ever were.

Even so, I really like Always Sunny. The characters in the show are quite possibly the most despicable protagonists in the history of television. They are the Worst People Ever, and they never improve, never learn lessons, and never win. The best that happens to them is they break even and are no further than they were when they started. While some episodes fall flat, the show is willing to plumb the depths of weirdness and does not shy away from offensive topics (which it tends to pull off well because the characters are already so loathsome that it doesn't actually hurt your opinion of them to see them stoop lower), making it the closest approximation to a live-action South Park that we're ever likely to see.

And that's my opinion. For the record, my current favorite comedy show is Community.
View user's profileSend private messageSend emailVisit poster's websiteAIM AddressICQ NumberYahoo MsgrMSN Msgr
TheBluebird
post-nerdal true geek ascendancy
Posts: 1485
Location: home is where the hearthstone is
Reply with quote
Posted 4.27.10 :: 2:49PM ::
I never watched more than an ep or two of Always Sunny, so maybe my vote is not fair, haha. But I love 30 Rock! I think it's very clever.

3PO, I love Community, too!

You know what sitcom is way funnier than I thought it'd be? Cougar Town. I thought it looked incredibly lame; like it would be just another stale sitcom. But it was created by the same dude that did Scrubs and that show was great.
View user's profileSend private messageVisit poster's websiteAIM Address
QuizMaster
ultranerd
Posts: 1153
Location: Vancouver, BC
Reply with quote
Posted 4.27.10 :: 7:20PM ::
Aye, I'm certainly digging Cougar Town as well. And Modern Family.

Can't say I've heard of the Philadephia show.
View user's profileSend private messageMSN Msgr
Previterror
hypernerd
Posts: 915
Location: Boise, ID
Reply with quote
Posted 4.27.10 :: 8:13PM ::
The Emotional Chicken game was just too god damned funny. I really like Cougar Town and watch all the episodes as they come out on Hulu.
View user's profileSend private messageSend emailAIM AddressYahoo MsgrMSN Msgr
kofman
geekist
Posts: 45
Location: Winter Park, FL
Reply with quote
Posted 4.27.10 :: 8:41PM ::
Aww man, really? 30 rock? I mean that show is funny half the time. While sunny is consistently stupid and hilarious. Theirs just no comparison.
View user's profileSend private messageVisit poster's website
Previterror
hypernerd
Posts: 915
Location: Boise, ID
Reply with quote
Posted 4.27.10 :: 9:31PM ::
kofman wrote:
sunny is consistently stupid


I'm with you up to this point.
View user's profileSend private messageSend emailAIM AddressYahoo MsgrMSN Msgr
Page 1 of 1    
See only topics
from the previous:


BBS :: Who Wants Pie? :: Thread
Previous thread :: Next thread
5.20.13 :: 5:50PM :: GMT - 4 Hours
Post New Topic
  You cannot post new threads here
You cannot reply to threads here
You cannot edit your posts here
You cannot delete your posts here
You cannot vote in polls here
Leap:  
It works because of phpBB © 2001-2006 phpBB Group